Friday, 27 May 2016

Toward a Christian Theology of Dialogic Communication at the Grassroots Level in a Multireligious Context



Toward a Christian Theology of Dialogic Communication at the Grassroots Level in a Multireligious Context
By Raja, Joshva
An article from Journal of Ecumenical Studies, Vol. 43, No. 4 Fall 2008 Pages 562-576.


Dialogue at Grassroots
Dialogue at grassroots means communication between two persons or two communities or two caste groups or two nations who are not intellectuals nor are leaders or representatives rather simple people. At the church level it is the lay people who are neither theologians nor pastors nor preachers rather simple members of the church who would venture dialogue with simple lay people or followers of other faiths. My aim is to promote dialogue between such grassroots level people who are strong believers and would like to live a simple faith of their own. Previous attempts to hold dialogue was carried out mainly at intellectual and leadership levels. Many of such attempts led to failures due to fear of accepting syncretism and of taking an exclusive pluralistic position. Dialogue at grassroots refers to establishing contact, communication, relationship and understanding between communities. This would mean to enrich the process that already exists in many contexts such as tea shops or petty shops where dialogue as a process between people of different faiths is happening; to enable people to use dialogue as a means to address many of the social problems including religious conflicts; and also to enable the confronting communities together to find a way to live together.


Christians and Dialogue
People keep on asking me to state my theological position on dialogue at grassroots explicitly. In this article I would like to focus on developing a theological framework for Christian communities that they may be persuaded towards holding dialogue with other communities. What prevents Christian lay members often to hold a dialogue with other religious communities is the misunderstanding that dialogue is against their evangelistic mission. They also think that by holding dialogue they may have to give up their claims of uniqueness. Many may believe that dialogue is only for intellectuals as they deal with Sanskrit terms and understand relationship between religious texts and so on. Many also think that dialogue means to accept the position that all religions lead people to the same God. Inter-Religious dialogue is often misunderstood at grassroots giving one or the other reasons as stated above.

Dialogue
Dialogue means to establish contact, presence, communication, relationship and understanding between persons or communities. If this is the case it does not demand change in the persons or communities concerned. Such a dialogue affirms life of each other person or community; enables people to share their basic resources; guides people to recognize each other’s search for God and leads people to recognize common human values such as justice and dignity. Every human being tries to search for God through his or her own ways using his or her own religious or non-religious or even anti-religious means and methods. Such a willingness to search for God should be recognized in all persons and thus engaging in each other’s search can be seen as dialogue. Religious narratives are supposed to guide people to engage in search for meanings of life and of God in a particular way. Before I discuss about the theological framework for dialogical communication at grassroots, I would like to highlight a few scholarly understanding of dialogue between people and communities. This may help us to recognize the importance of recognizing the dialogue within and then with the other rather than thinking only in terms of dialogue with the other. I have selected a few scholars who attempted to highlight the importance of dialogue. They have also argued that dialogue can solve many of the social issues and problems.

Freire
Dialogue is understood by scholars in different ways. Paulo Freire [1972,1987] in his concept of dialogical method in education pointed out that dialogue is the encounter between persons, mediated by the world, in order to name the world. He demanded people to explore the idea and its roots. Dialogue is not merely conversation between people but establishing relationship between beings through communication of the being itself. Such communication should be critical and creative in the encounter between persons and should lead to conscientization. The dialogue for Freire should create a critical consciousness among the members of the learning community. Such a dialogue should lead to action (praxis) in which the culture of silence of the masses should be broken. For Freire dialogue refers to a critical learning process between the teacher and the student in which both are involved as participants of liberative reflection and praxis.

Gadamer
Gadamer [1979:347] uses the word ‘conversation’ that he describes as a process of two people understanding each other. It is a process in which each opens himself to the other person, accepts the other’s point of view as worthy of consideration and gets inside the other to the extent that he understands not the individual but what the other says. For him the horizons for the present (interaction with the other) merge with the horizons of the past (prejudices and traditional thinking) and thus continually grow together to making of living value without either being explicitly distinguished from the other. One has to put one’s own prejudices and understandings to the test. By seeking to discover other people’s standpoint and horizon their ideas become intelligible without one necessarily having to agree with them [Gadamer 1979:270]. For Gadamer dialogue is the basic mode of human understanding. Dialogue is not reproduce one’s meanings internally, but to produce unique meanings from the interpretative interchange that might be unpredictable from knowing the each other’s intentions. To interpret, one questions texts dialogically and allows texts to question us. Words are not tools of communication but the environment in which communication becomes possible. Dialogue as conversation is not being conducted but dialogue conducts participants, taking them over in surprising ways.

Bakhtin
Bakhtin explains dialogue in terms of human life. For him life by its very nature is dialogic. To live means to participate in dialogue. He says, “To live means to participate in dialogue: to ask questions, to heed, to respond, to agree and so forth. In this dialogue a person participates wholly and throughout his whole life; with his eyes, lips, hands, soul, spirit, with his whole body and deeds. He invests his entire self in discourse and this discourse enters into the dialogic fabric of human life, into the world symposium [Bakhtin 1984:293]. Bakhtin is concerned about the language and its meanings. He uses the term ‘Heteroglossia’ to describe the inscription of multiple voices engage in dialogue within the text. For him dialogue is the dialectical relationship between self and other where self occupies a relative center, and thus requires the other for existence. For Bakhtin dialogue is a process that is woven into the very basis of language itself. Language is inherently dialogue-each word reverberating with the history of its voicings and through language human experience becomes inherently multiple. A self or consciousness to Bakhtin is not a singular possession, is not mine or yours but instead inherently depends upon otherness.

Buber
Martin Buber conceive dialogue as a process in which the other is fully recognized. Dialogue is a process in which communicators turn toward each other in full recognition of how particular and unique the other is, confirming him or her while remaining fully ready to be surprised by what the other offers. Martin Buber [1958, p 15] uses two phrases, ‘I-Thou’ and ‘I-It’, to describe two different type of attitude to the other (includes world). The ‘I-Thou’ highlights relationship with nature, persons and spiritual beings whereas ‘I-It’ points to the relationship with material objects or depersonalized human beings. The latter reduces people into a matter or a thing [1958:19]. The former attitude enables a person to accept the whole being of the other without awareness of the parts. The dialogue guides to a non-reductionist, unconditional and unified unselfconscious relationship between I and thou. The I-Thou relations demands total commitment. IT can be spoken with one’s whole being. A human being is transfigured into authentic life only by entering an I-Thou relationship, therewith confirming the otherness of the other.

Buber argues that One cannot live without dialogue. The person who never met a Thou is not really a human being. Dialogue demands risks in which I-Thou demands a total exposure of the I, which may be denied and rejected. While the subjective I-Thou reality exists in the terrain of dialogue, the instrumental I-It relationship is anchored in monologue. The monologue transforms the world and mankind into an object. Within the monological domain, the other is regarded as a thing among things— experienced and used, whereas in the dialogical sphere the other is met, acknowledged and addressed as a particular being. Dialogue is more than mere exchange of words or script.

Dialogue happens between people whether in words or in silence where each of the participants really has in mind the other or others in their present and particular being and turns to them with the intention of establishing a living mutual relation between himself and them" (Arnett, p.6, 1986). The last characteristic of true dialogue involves meaning. Dialogue allows participants to create new meaning together and come to a mutual understanding. In dialogue, meaning is actually discovered between persons rather than owned by each individual. This concept encourages one to recognize that there is meaning beyond what is inside of him/her (Arnett, 1986). Parties relate to and experience each other as objects or means to achieving goals in an I-it relationship. This relation contains only regard for self. Buber does not suggest that we are to avoid this type of relationship, he merely claims that dialogue cannot occur in the I-it relation. Dialogue is unique because it evolves through a process and particular quality of communication whereby parties achieve a "connection." This connection between participants allows for each party to potentially change the other, or be changed by the other.


Habermas
For Habermas Dialogue is establishing a rational discourse between individuals in the public sphere. Such a dialogue should lead to a realization of enlightenment values. By identifying these essential presuppositions to argumentation, Habermas completes his argument for the universal principle. If, whenever discussing a claim to validity, one must follow the rules of logical sense, assume a hypothetical attitude toward the relevant facts, and ensure the free and equal status of all the participants in the dialogue, then Habermas can derive the principle of discourse ethics: a norm is valid only if it meets the free approval of every person that may be affected. He contrasted dialogic concepts such as the ideal speech situation (aimed at arriving consensus through arguments with equal access and equal opportunities to speak and question others’ speech) to the monological and authoritarian consciousness by which people are subjugated.


David Bohm
For Bohm dialogue means ‘flowing through’ amongst people rather than an exchange of a game of ping-pong. The word ‘discussion’ really means ‘to break up everything’ to analyse and have an exchange, like a game. The spirit of dialogue is not competition, but it means we find something new, then everybody wins [Bohm 1998: 117-118]. Dialogue is a process where one suspends one’s opinions, holding them in front of you, while neither suppressing them, nor insisting upon them. It is not an attempt to convince the other but simply to understand. First step is to understand the meanings of everybody together without having to make any decisions or saying who is right and who is wrong. This might create a common consciousness which is new and where everyone enfolds the whole consciousness.
Bohm proposed that we live in a holographic universe. Every part of the universe both contains and contributes to the whole. If one part is affected by something (some change), it affects the whole and vice versa. Thus, we live in a relational world where the individual impacts the collective and the collective impacts the individual. The difficulty is that our thinking causes us to behave as though the opposite were true: that we live in a fragmented world where individual parts are separate from each other. Our thinking process works against our ability to perceive the interconnections and the whole.
Bohm offers dialogue as a means to uncover and correct incoherence. By pooling our individual perspectives in an environment of non-judgment, a larger view of reality becomes possible. We can start to perceive the necessary linkages between our actions and the results we get. Through dialogue we can participate in collective thinking. We no longer have to take actions based on limited understanding. Bohmian dialogue aims at the unfolding of collective intelligence.
David Bohm maintained that if we could become conscious of our thinking process we might be able to create a different kind of culture, one based on a holographic view of the universe. Such a culture would bridge the needs of the individual and the collective leading to increasingly deeper levels of community and adaptation to the environment. Two important challenges for us have been how to best facilitate people's ability to participate in dialogue and then how to help them continue the practice and experience all of the possible ways it can enhance the group.
David Bohm speculated that thought itself is not the result of an individual in isolation, but is largely a collective phenomenon. A story creates a dialogue-like space in a free flow of meaning that passes and moves through and between people, in the sense of a stream that flows between the banks. As in dialogue, a group accesses a large pool of common meaning which cannot be fully accessed individually.
A Critique
All the above definitions and directions for dialogue hold well in so far as the person concern is willing to converse with the other. In those contexts where the participants are neither willing to listen nor willing to change in any way in their belief it is very difficult to talk about openness and freedom of speech. These definitions also look at the self or personhood as being influenced by the other and influence the other. The self is placed either in contrast to or in relation to or along with the other. The communication process between the participants of the dialogue can happened either through critical learning and praxis (Freire), rational discourse (Habermas), I-Thou relationship (Buber), merging horizons of past and present (Gadamer), dialogic-language (Bakhtin) and through common consciousness (Bohm). Their emphasis is on the dialogic relationship of one with the other and tends to answer how to develop a dialogic link between people. Without a person deciding whether to participate in the dialogue or not there is no possibility of developing dialogic relationship among the participants. The above definitions highlight the process of dialogue between the self and the other and thus dialogue is explained in terms of relationship with the other. Their emphasis on the other is important and its role in shaping the self should also be recognized. Without a dialogue within oneself from different perspectives it may be difficult to extend it with the other. It is not essential to change any perspectives or the self in order to extend the dialogue with the other. Nevertheless one may have to recognize within oneself the presence of difference perspectives, beliefs and views that are in constant dialogue with each other. Though one holds one’s own perspective strongly one can still attempt to listen to the voices of the other perspectives within oneself because it is the nature of God in human self. In such a belief one’s life, dignity and faith become important and so dialogue with the other on this basis may become possible at any level include people at grassroots.

Dialogue is a process in which individuals or communities are engaged in search for meanings of life together and of God at times. There must be willingness to come and participate in this process from each individual. The individual may allow himself or herself to be open for changes or may not allow himself or herself to be changed. Without developing a dialogic attitude within a person it is difficult to establish dialogic relationship among the participants. In order to develop such attitude one has to look at the self and the existence of different perspectives within one’s own self. By holding dialogue or by recognizing different perspectives within the self there is a possibility developing dialogical attitude among the people. This paper attempts to venture into a theological framework of developing such a dialogical attitude among people.

Different Methods of Dialogue
The dialogue needs to be recognized in different ways – dialogue for searching spiritual meanings (life after death), dialogue for action together (eliminating poverty), dialogue for intellectual enquiry (God as creator) and dialogue for life together (overcoming conflicts). One also needs to recognize the fact that many attempts are already made (process) and many places in villages and urban areas simple dialogue between individuals and groups are happening between different religious groups. This is what we can call as ‘ongoing processes’ of dialogue at grassroots. Such kind of processes has to be recognized and enriched by anyone who wants to involve in this process. People do use to come together for action such as promoting awareness about HIV/AIDS together or campaigning against child labour and so on. This can be called as ‘means’ of dialogue at grassroots. Dialogue is used as means to promote an action together among different religious communities. In places where people do not want to talk about their religion and their faith this is the best way to bring people together and enable them to act together.

There may be many possibilities to explore this way of dialogue. There are communities who do not want to live with other communities. In such contexts it is essential that we establish contact, relationship and understanding between these communities in order to bring them together and enable them to live together. In many villages in Gujarat people are sent out because of their religion. The political leadership has emotionalized people to segregate them from others. There one has to struggle through pamphlets and other methods of communication and create awareness among the majority community. The majority’s religion needs to be reinterpreted in order to make them to recognize and accept the minority community back to their village. The political ideology may have to be exposed to the majority community in the villages. The way we do mission has to be completely changed in such contexts. Such dialogue has to be understood as an ‘end’ in itself. Establishing dialogue between communities itself is the task in such contexts.


Religion and Dialogue
Very often religious narratives and institutions have become exploitative and discriminatory in nature. They were supposed to help people to establish relationship with God and with neighbour. But very often they have misguided their followers and made them to destroy other people in the name of serving God and defending religion and culture. In this way religious narratives and institutions are not necessarily guiding people to God and to other people though they are supposed to do so. There are narratives of religion, caste, political groups and so on that often shape, reflect and influence people’s relationship, communication and understanding of life and faith. The narratives of religion are supposed to help us to relate ourselves to God and with others. Because they are diverse we are exposed to the wide range of narratives and thus to perspectives. When we are exposed to these narratives our self becomes active recognizing different perspectives within ourselves. These diverse narratives evolve from the experience of God of human beings. The experience is different because within Godhood there are many perspectives exist without losing an underlying unity as well. The unity is not the uniformity rather oneness comes as a result of dynamic, creative and interactive Godhood in whom many perspectives coexist and cooperate in developing perfection. The oneness is not sameness rather an acceptance of multiple perspectives existing in one personhood and linking each perspective with dignity and relationship.


For such a dialogue one does not need to change one’s own faith even if it is exclusive in nature. For example many Christians believe that Jesus is the way, the truth and the life and there is no other way, truth and life. Christians do not need to change this faith in Jesus in order to have dialogue with other religious friends. If we Christians do not wish to change our faith in Christ, in dialogue we do not need to expect others to change their faith in their respective Gods in order to have dialogue with us. This does not mean that we accept their faith as same as our faith. We have the experience of our own faith and may know that our faith is the true faith but we do not experience the other person’s faith. Thus we do not know how the other person had experienced God in his or her own life and so we cannot make any judgment on their faith experience. The other person may believe that his or her faith is the true faith and has similar or different experience to confirm such claims.



Dialogue and Perspectives
Dialogue must lead to co-existence of different persons and communities. In order to co-exist, claims of truth too must be allowed to coexist. We are not working with plurality or with post modernity. I do not argue that there are many ways to approach God or to reach the truth. Truth within Godhood at times can collide, confront, nourish each other, just exist together with difference between them and grow together. I strongly argue that there are different perspectives of a truth that have oneness underlying them within Godhood. It does not mean to argue that there are many truths and so there are many gods. Not only narratives and experience that make the difference in approaching God and truth but also there is a possibility of Godhood that consists of a coexistence of multiple truths. It is also possible that God revealed himself in this way and allowed people to conceive him, as one who holds multiple truths together in himself. We are working with people’s search for God and ultimate truth. Religious narratives try to help the respective believers to find meanings of God and of life within their descriptions and thus guide them to have an experience of God in their lives. Each narrative having been supported strongly by their followers is claimed to be having the ultimate truth and thus is claimed to be the universally exclusive truth. With such claims of narratives and guided meanings my search is to find whether different truths coexist within Godhood that may lead to a dialogue between such exclusive claims and narratives. If it is true that God himself contains a multiplicity of truths and has established a successful dialogue within him between these truths, then why not people who claim to have experience and narratives of exclusive truths can also find a way to coexist and hold dialogue among them.

Dialogue and Bible
As I am concerned to develop a theological framework for Christians to develop dialogue with other religious communities without loosing their identity or without changing their faith in Christ and thus find a way to live together and share basic human values such as justice and dignity of each other. Not only to establish a dialogue between Christians and others but also to encourage Christian communities to become means of furthering this dialogue between other religious communities too. Thus a culture of dialogue and a culture of peace and justice could be established rather than a culture of confrontation, a culture of terror and a culture of ignorance. Only through dialogue at grassroots many of the religious, caste and linguistic issues can be addressed and the communities can be brought together towards peace and justice. In order to develop a theological framework I look at the Biblical narratives and at times narratives of other religious texts as well and see whether we can see through the experience of Biblical communities - a God who is basically a God of dialogue. There is a need for Christians to initiate this dialogue. Bringing people closer to Christ means to enable them to recognize the divine ‘self’s in them and thus engage with the image of God within their self and thus realize God’s presence in them. In order to do this the dialogue should be seen as part of mission of the church.

Dialogue and Contextual needs
The need for such a dialogue arises from a few contextual reasons and demands. A). People need to share their resources. As the people have increased in numbers the resources of food and energy have become limited. People struggle for their daily livelihood and so look for someone to help them. There are political, religious and social opportunists who create a religious, political or social narrative to blame the other for all their problems. Without sharing the minimum resources for existence it is difficult for coexistence. In order to share people’s resources dialogue is the best method to bring about changes both at structural and individual level. B). People are often ignorant of other communities. Such ignorance and negative information about other communities are being popularized through mass media and also by the local media. This creates a monolithic and stereotypic image of the other in the mind of the each community. Such images make the other as enemy and threat to the culture, religion and even the existence of the community itself. This is also developed as religious narrative of hatred towards others that are fixed and exclusive to the extent of eliminating other communities. C). The world is shrinking in terms of globalization through different media. People were made to believe that their culture is being threatened by the outside cultures such as Western or Islamic culture. Thereby the local conservative culture is shown as decaying in the onslaught of the liberal culture that is being promoted by the media and by other global forces.

The local fundamental forces show themselves as defenders of the local culture and show the other religious groups or other people as outsiders who are bringing these liberal values into the local context and thus are seen as destroyers of the local culture and religious practices. Neo-liberal values with the enforced global capitalism tend to commercialize everything including life and convert everything on earth into a saleable good. People’s lives are also being sold like a consumer product which is seen as threat to many people’s existence. Many political and religious groups are highlighting this problem and creating religious narratives to protect their people and their culture. This too creates a tension between ideological groups. D). Very often people are faced with natural disasters such as draught, flood, earthquakes, Tsunamis and so on. There is no proper mechanism to address these disasters together. Often charity leads the way for a while then later affected people are forgotten left to live or die with whatever resources that are available to them. Some time ago people ate mango kernel and died of hunger and malnutrition in Orissa. This shows clearly that people start becoming Naxalites (extreme Marxists) or terrorists or robbers in their respective places. In such contexts without dialogic action there is no way forward rather the society collapses. Dialogic action involves not only discussions but also an action of sharing the resources and addressing the issues such as natural disaster and neo-liberalism together.

There are many other reasons for the dialogue between persons and communities in order to address these issues and problems. As I mentioned as already the aim of the dialogue is to create a new humanity where life is affirmed, resources are shared, each one’s faith is respected, human dignity is recognized and relationship is nourished. The theology needs to move in this direction. For me my method is to look at the Biblical images of God who provides a model of interactive and dialogic communication.


Dialogue in God
Biblical God is a God of Dialogue. God is a Communitarian and Trinitarian God. In him[1] there is a community of God. The Book of Genesis (Chapter 1) informs us about God in plurality (Let us create human being in our image). It also provides the picture of God as one who communicates within himself. This communication involves both listening and speaking. God has to be understood as a community of God in oneness. There is also a dialogue within this community of God at times. God holds dialogue with Satan in the book of Job (Chapter 1). Within the parliament of God Satanic voices are equally heard and are listened to by God. This does not mean that Satan is part of God as Jung would like us to imagine. Even with the opposite parties, God contacts, listens, communicates and establishes relationship. He communicates with the other that shows that God establishes perfect communication even with the opponent by listening and speaking with him (1 Kings 22). God also lets part of his community to play the role of the opponent in the life of the human beings. The underlying unity of God does not refer to the uniformity of perspectives and ideas. The oneness does not refer to sameness of personalities within the community of God. The Trinitarian concepts explain to us the way different personalities exist within the oneness of God (Dynamic Monotheism).


Jung and Opposites within
Such a concept of God holding dialogue with the opposite and playing the role of the opposite is slightly different from Jungian concept of ‘Opposites within God’. For Jung God is the archetype image of collective unconscious. Jung argues that Christianity is dualistic and if it claims to be monotheism, then the opposites must be contained in God. In God, insight goes together with obtuseness, and "loving-kindness along with cruelty." The coexistence of these opposites means God is unconscious or just feebly conscious. Both good and evil exist in God so He is a "totality of inner opposites", and God "does not care a rap for any moral opinion and does not recognize any form of ethics as binding." [Jung C W 11.p.358-369]. Jung argued that the Old Testament reflects the primitive human beings’ concept of God. They conceived God as one who was unconscious and morally primitive. Jung points out that the paradoxical nature of God has an effect on humanity: it splits us into opposites and delivers us over to a seemingly insoluble conflict. Psychologically, what happens in such situations of conflict the unconscious in any number of ways (dreams, faery tales, myths, etc.) throws out sings of the union of opposites as symbolized by a variety of means--the child-hero, squaring the circle, etc. This is precisely the type of figure we find in the vision of the Sun Woman, whose whole story is a reiteration of the birth of Christ. To Jung this is a motif that appears again in the dreams of modern humans and it always has to do with the bring together the darkness with the light. This union of opposites is a problem that the revelation set out, that alchemists have tried to resolve for seven centuries and that confronts modern people.

God and Many voices
Within God there are multiple voices and perspectives underlying oneness but holding dialogue among them. This shows the nature of God in the Bible as one who is dynamic and interactive God. The prophets show us that the God is one who accepts all as his people. It means not only Israelites are the chosen race but even others are called and led by God just like Israelites. In Isaiah chapter 19, God calls Egypt his people and Assyrians as his handwork and Israelites as his chosen race. In this sense God is shown as universal God who leads every culture and people according to his ways and teachings. He reveals in every culture and religion his ways. God engaged in different communities in revealing himself. With specific purposes he might have revealed diverse perspectives to people of God. No religion and no culture are perfect in describing God and so they can only serve people to relate themselves with God and with one’s neighbour. They have often failed in their basic objectives rather they have misled people against God and against their own neighbour.

God is seen as one who establishes contacts, communicates, renews relationship and develop understanding with himself, with others, even with his opponents and with those whom he may not agree with. This is because within Godhood there are multiple perspectives that are in constant dialogue. This is what I call as God’s dialogue that needs to be recognized and should be extended to human relationship as well. There are many other examples in the Old Testament that portray God as one who listens, communicates and understand the others (Isaiah). It is interesting to note that the change in God is to be seen as inbuilt nature itself rather than to see him as one who changes from righteousness to unrighteousness. This is because God is a dynamic God and not a static God. God tends to recognize different perspectives that he may understand human being better and breaks his rules (such as Sabbath), transcend law of nature (Clock set backwards) and changes himself at times in order to re-establish relationship with human beings.

God can be seen as an exclusive God who does not want his creation to worship any other than himself while he has to be recognized by all and is working through other people to bring Israelites the chosen people back to him. So God is also working among and through other people besides the chosen people of God. In this way Bible projects God as both exclusive as well as inclusive of different people and their faith. God is also seen as one who is engaged not only with Israelites but also with others in their search for meanings of God and of life. In every culture and communities God has been working in some ways that have been developed into a religious narrative and structure. Whether every religion (its institution and narrative) leads one back to God is not possible for anyone to conclude or affirm.


Dialogue and the Word
In terms of establishing contact, relationship and understanding with human beings God breaks his own natural law, religion, reason and science and thus become a son for a lady who did not follow the natural rules to beget a baby. The expected messiah is dwelling among people in an unexpected and unacceptable format. Then people did not understand that the Word can only become flesh and dwell in the form of a simple human being called Jesus. The protestant equation of Word with word is a major disaster in theological thinking. The Word can never be equated to oral or written or visual word. The words can only interpret the Word event and cannot objectify Word into a narrative. The Word can only be experienced by people in the form of flesh. Human spoken or written word can only provide multiple descriptions of Word that should lead to its experience.

When the experience of the Word is narrated in human words this leads to diversity of narratives. No single narrative can claim to be absolute and perfect. The purpose of the narrative is to lead us to experience the Word which is ultimately with God and is God. We accept limitations in human communication. The Word can only become and can communicate through incarnation and life of Jesus Christ. Jesus is the embodiment of the Word. Because human communication is constrained by its limitation, even the narrative about Jesus has to be shared through four Gospels that are different at times in narrating the events. The early followers were not like five blind men who experienced the elephant rather five men with their eyes opened, ears listening and hands touching experienced Jesus as a historic person and then narrated his story in different ways. That is why we have four Gospels that the followers of Jesus and early Christian Community wanted the later readers to recognize their difficulties in presenting Jesus in an absolute way. Even today this can happen in someone’s life with all sorts of video and audio recorders.

Dialogue in Jesus
Jesus can also be seen as a role model in dialogic communication. He established contact, relationship and understanding with others including those who were identified as sinners by the community. Jesus engaged in discussion with his contemporaries – such as Pharisees and Sadducees who were often opposed to some of Jesus’ radical views. He created a public sphere by holding dialogue with them and challenging them within their own narratives. He was so critical about their interpretations and their authority. Nevertheless he was not undermining the narratives of faith that they shared with him. Jesus shared many perspectives with his disciples as well as with his listeners. Very often Jesus had dialogue within himself from different perspectives. He shared this dialogue with God whom he called as ‘My Father’ and also with his disciples. He was struggling to decide on taking up the cup of suffering and prayed to Father to remove it if possible. This shows a dialogue within himself that he extends with God. When Jesus had dialogue with those who were questioning his teachings, he was listening, recognizing and trying to establish understanding with them. Though his expectations to convince the other groups failed he was not giving up either. He was anguish at the Father even at the cross by asking ‘Why did you forsake me?’ But his mission was to hold contact, dialogue, relationship and understanding with all people with whom he was interacting. This is a greatest model for us to hold dialogue with others even those who are opposed to our perspectives and views. Jesus did not change his vision and teaching of the Kingdom of God rather he was trying to enable the opponents to see the problems within their interpretations and approaches. Through dialogue he continued to interact with people from every corner of the society regardless of their refusal to accept him and his teachings.

This sets us a Christology for our dialogue. Jesus tells people that there is no other name besides my name on earth. He also asks his disciples to proclaim the Gospel to the entire world. He says, ‘I am the Truth, the Life and the Way. In many ways he is presented as an exclusive person. At the same time there are instances where he accommodates others as they are. He accepts the Samaritan women and tells her that God will be worshipped everywhere. He also tells the gentile man who was healed from among the graves to go back to his people and proclaim what (his) God has done to him. He wants his disciples to accept him and him only. But when it comes in terms of other religions he seems to hold a dialogic and listening style. For Jesus the religious narratives are secondary to people and their lives when he says Sabbath is made for human beings rather than human beings for Sabbath. He recognizes people’s faith in God and appreciated them. Even at one point of time he was convinced by the gentile lady’s faith who was praying to heal her daughter. He recognized and emphasized the importance of people’s lives, their faith the need to share resources among themselves and their relationship with each other. Jesus is presented in the Gospels as inclusive as well as exclusive. He might have been exclusive when he says go to Israelites only but might have been inclusive when he says to Samaritan Lady that God will be worshipped everywhere.

Jesus can also be seen as one who heals the deaf and dumb people and as one who dines with tax collectors and sinners. Thereby he affirms the life of these people and makes them whole. His mission is to guide the people to recognize in themselves, realize along with others and thus become divine beings in this world. For Jesus this means to enable the people to become a full human being. If a person cannot speak and hear, Jesus makes him a fuller human being by enabling him to speak and listen. If there are not many chances for tax collectors and sinners to listen due to the rejection of the main stream society, then Jesus goes there to listen and speak to them. Jesus also listens to his opponents and contemporary leaders who want to eliminate him and then attempts to interact with them by engaging in their search for meanings. By listening Jesus communicates and for communicating Jesus listens. Because Jesus communicates within himself from different perspectives as an extension of his communication with God he was able to hold dialogue with anyone with different perspectives. He also creates an atmosphere to have dialogue with the other and thus attempts to lead the humanity towards becoming a divine community that is the body of Christ (church).


Dialogue and God’s Self
Having discussed about God and Christ from a dialogic perspective, one should not give away the importance the uniqueness the Christianity has contributed to the humanity. Dialogue between different perspectives does not mean that one should try to share a little bit of each perspective or harmony of the perspectives or consensus from these perspectives. God is working with a particular purpose for this world. At the same time God is also engaging with human being to carry out this purpose by accommodating human beings’ perspectives as well. God holds the dialogue within himself from different perspectives and so the purpose of establishing relationship with human beings is served by extending such dialogue with human beings as well. In case he finds a perspective is relevant which is against his perspective but works with human beings then he adopts and tests it and uses it for communicating with human beings. If a person does not hold on to a particular perspective it would lead to confusion and chaos. But at the same time without a dialogue from other perspectives within oneself, the self fails to recognize the image of God within and thus loses the purpose of his life. When it comes in terms of different religion, God is also active in every person and his or her culture.

From people’s experience of God they construct their own religion to enable the future generation to have similar experience and relate themselves with God and also with other. Each religious narrative is a construction of human beings from their experience of God and of life. These narratives have limitations in terms of linguistic expressions, narration, semantic constructions, and historical accuracies and so on. This does not prevent people from believing and practicing them. When it is relating people to God and to neighbour the religions seem to be working within a particular religious community. But when it is extended to other religion or cultural groups, then there are issues such as conversion and The problem comes only when we provide an adjective to God and neighbour such as Christian or Jewish or Hindu God or Christian or Jewish or Hindu neighbour. If God is universal then there is no need for any adjective (Christian God or Hindu God or Muslim God) to be added to him. If he is approachable by people, each one’s faith in God can be recognized as the starting point rather than religion. Jesus often recognized people’s faith in God and appreciated them for their belief in him. Even in the case of neighbours the same conclusion is applicable. There is no need to have adjectives for neighbours such as Christian sister or Hindu friends and Muslim brother and so on to share our love and care with others. When any neighbour regardless becomes our friend, partner or brother then the dialogic relationship brings the God’s reign here and now. It means one should be ready to accept any neighbour as my friend and as my fellow faith seeker, there we express the image of God to other and thus witness God’s love the whole world.

This takes us to the next step of theology where we discover ourselves in the light of God’s Self. Each one of us has multiple ‘personalities’ in ourselves. A person’s attitude, speech and relationship are often shaped by the perspectives that he or she has. Such perspectives are shaped and formed by many social institutions including religion, family, peer group, school and media. If one holds more than two perspectives in oneself on a particular issue at a particular historical time then there is a dialogue possible within one’s ‘self’. If one holds only one perspective without having dialogue with another perspective then no dialogue is possible within oneself and with others. Such single perspective persons do not mind giving up their lives for the sake of such perspectives. This may lead to martyrdom and also to suicide bombers. People may allow themselves to be persecuted or to be killed for the sake of establishing relationship with God and also relationship with neighbours. Such kind of martyrdom may be interpreted positively. At the same time if the martyrdom is carried for fixed doctrines or ‘single’ perspectives then such an act can be interpreted as an act of terror or suicide.


Dialogue and Single Perspective
Single perspectives tend to divide humanity and take people away from God who is a Universal God and also inclusive of different perspectives. Those who hold fundamentalist views often tend to hold single perspective. For them dialogue is not possible within themselves and so dialogue is not possible with others. But when it comes in terms of their own ‘self’s or their related ‘self’s being affected by such perspectives, then they try to see from other perspectives. In Kanyakumari (Southern Tip of India) Catholics and Protestants were staying together for many years in the nearby village. Catholics rarely visited Protestant churches nor did Protestant go to Catholic churches among these villages. But when Tsunami came both communities lost their houses and their beloved people and were forced to live together for more than three months in the CSI church (protestant). This brought a contact, discussion and relationship between these two denominational communities at grassroots. Many of them come to know about the other and discovered God in the other. We do not need to wait for another disaster to bring people together regardless of their identities.

Many of the religious people who hold single perspectives often find it difficult to come out of it though it destroys them very often. This is not only true with the religious groups but also with those who strongly believe in the modernism and rationalism. Many of these groups such as Marxists and neo-liberalists strongly believe in single perspective that they think should be upheld and practiced at all costs. When they are convinced they tend to eliminate all other systems of thought and perspective within themselves and also with other selves as well. I also believe that persons who hold single perspectives do share other perspectives but tend to suppress within themselves other perspectives through rationalism, liberal thinking and modern scientific demonstrations. Many of them think that they know their ‘self’s completely. The mystic side of the self cannot be understood and explained by anyone except the experience the person about his or her own self.


Dialogue within Self
A person has multiple perspectives within his or her self. But he is convinced of one perspective at one point of time and uses another perspective at another point of time and place. These two perspectives may overlap, work on the same principle and operate within the relationship with other persons. At times these two or more perspectives may contradict one another because of the context and historical setting. In this way the person concern may hold dialogue between two perspectives within oneself. Most of the people have such nature though often they do not accept the fact that they have different perspectives within their ‘self’s and hold dialogue between them at times. For example someone may talk against drug users but when it comes it someone’s daughter or son taking drugs, they begin to look at from another perspective taking the reality and adjustment into account. The reason is that they cannot throw their son or daughter out of their house because of the use of drugs though the society may not accept him or her. The opposite or different perspectives exist in everyone’s mindset. It is the recognition of these perspectives within oneself that enables one to hold the dialogue within.

It is also essential not only the perspectives within oneself but also to make an attempt to understand the other person’s perspective without making a judgment from one self experience of a particular perspective. Only when there is a dialogue within oneself, there is a possibility of expanding such dialogue with the other. It is this attempt to look at other’s perspective from within the self that makes people to develop a willingness to hold dialogue with others. One needs to discover within oneself a Godhood of multiple perspectives. It is because of the image of God in us we have this multiple perspectives within our ‘self’s and a desire to communicate with opposite views and voices within self. Because God communicates within himself from different perspectives the image of God within human beings tends to represent such characteristics of dialogue within. Those who try to hold only one perspective and impose on themselves and others tend to suppress other perspectives within and thus subdue them into non-perspective systems. At times such sidelined perspectives disturb the person in his or her thinking or behaviour and thus erupt into abnormal or possibly violent behaviour.


Gestalt Therapy and Dialogue within
Such a dialogue within the self is not similar to the practice of self-dialogue in Gestalt Therapy Method. The Gestalt method works towards integration of different parts of the clients whereas this dialogue within enables the person to become aware of different perspectives within his or her self, recognize and establish contact between them and without changing two perspectives can be in constant dialogue with each other. The dialogic communication does not need to make one perspective bad and the other good. It should lead to recognition of the fact that there is a dominant or powerful or majoritarian perspective within the self. Such perspectives are sidelining the less powerful and minority perspectives within. If there is a constant dialogue between these perspectives then there is willingness for the person to explore dialogue with any ‘other’. This leads to a dialogical attitude towards others who hold different perspectives than ours. Gestalt self-dialogue is also a practical step (empty chair technique) to help a person to hold dialogue within oneself to get in touch with one’s own feelings that one is not aware of and to help one to integrate different parts within oneself. In this dialogue the attempt is not to eliminate one perspective for the other rather to see how best different perspectives within oneself can contribute to the overall personality in different contexts at different historical time with different people.


Voice Dialogue and Dialogue within
Hal Stone and Sidra Stone have rightly recognized the different personalities and many selves within everyone. Using Jungian concept they try to practice the voice dialogue therapy through which they identified a dialogic communication between different perspectives within one’s self. They maintained the opposites as they are without integrating one into the other. They did not have opposites try to talk to each other because they found that the purpose of having the parts talk to one another was usually to help effect some kind of reconciliation through change and accommodation. Instead, they allowed each self to remain true to itself. There is nothing inherently wrong with having two different selves talk to each other, however, so long as the autonomy of each self is respected and the therapist's underlying motivation is not reconciliation.
They showed the same respect to each self that we would show to a person. They allowed each self to grow and to change at its own rate and in its own way. Trying to get opposites reconciled seemed to be a way of trying to control peoples' lives, a way of controlling the therapy. They became aware of the tension created in us when we had to live with the reality of opposites in another person. They began to see how the need to reconcile opposites and thus solve problems for others was a function of their own inability to live with the tension of these opposites in themselves.
In this voice dialogue there is a need for a facilitator who would enable the person to hold different voices within the self. This method emphasizes the need to become aware of different selves within us. But it does not inform us how to hold dialogue between these selves while trying to respect each of these on their own merit. This method of voice dialogue is very similar to the concept of dialogue between different perspectives within the self. Nevertheless the main focus in this article is on making aware, establishing contact, holding dialogue and expanding relationship between different perspectives within the self. In such case we do not need play different role at different time in order to recognize different perspectives within ourselves. If one can hold dialogue within oneself between these different perspectives then a dialogical attitude may be created in him or her that would lead him or her to a dialogue with the other. This dialogue enables a person to grow further into a dialogic self with dialogic attitude to the other and thus recognizing the difficulty of coming to a particular perspective within a particular context at a historical time.

Perspectives, Self and Dialogue
Dialogue within the self refers to recognizing different perspectives of truth, views and beliefs that are part of the personhood. This dialogue can be a critical, rational, and existential in nature and so on. While holding on to the single belief system or claims of exclusive truth or ethnocentric views, there is a need to recognize other belief systems, other claimed truths and other views that exist within self. If a particular person does not recognize this single perspective or belief system tend to make the self consumed by it. When other perspectives are ignored, the psychological and spiritual problems arise within the self and may cause collapse of the person when he or she recognizes within himself or herself the other side of the reality. Within the truth claims, the spoken truth (Tamil –Vaimai) does not need to be the same as that of objective truth (Unmai) that is in the mind. The useful truth (Nanmai) may not be considered as truth related to justice (Nermai). Within the self this dialogue between different aspects of truth happens. At times self recognizes the limitations, contextual realities and the need for adjustment related to the issues of truth, belief and views. The dialogue between different perspectives within the self has to be recognized in order to enable the image of God active within. Otherwise the self slowly looses the power of the image of God within those who tend to sideline those voices of God within.


Dialogue and Image of God
God’s image in them and thus tends to develop the characteristics of animal nature in them which is ignorant and immature in the approach to others. To overcome the animal nature in one’s self one needs to recognize multiple perspectives that are the characteristics of the image of God. One should also notice the fact that holding dialogue within oneself between different perspectives does not mean to present a confused or decision-less personality to others. We subscribe to a particular perspective at times but having dialogue within ourselves from another perspective enable us not to continue with the mistakes and wrong-doings of the past and thus create a present where each one will walk according to one’s own faith guided by God but in constant dialogue with other perspectives. Refusal to hold dialogue within self and with the other is to refuse to recognize the image of God within ourselves and in others.

God establishes contact with everyone including those who tend reject or oppose him. He tries to commune with human beings by establishing relationship and understanding. If God is of one perspective he would have not accepted people with other perspectives. When Israelites demanded for a King God lets Samuel to anoint a king for them and then God later promises the messiah would also come in the linearity of the King David. Within the limitations of understanding of human beings, within their expectations and within their negation God continues to communicate with them in order that they would respond to him. This dialogue is an extension of God’s dialogue within himself. Having many perspectives and views within his self and having dialogue between these perspectives, God extends such dialogue with human beings regardless of their rejection and opposition.


Recognizing the Dialogic Self
The perspectives within the self are at frictions, negotiations and rejections but tend to coexist with each other. At times one perspective is given more important than the other. In a particular context two perspectives are colliding within the self and still one can neither eliminate the other nor negotiate with the other. There may not be a consensus rather an acceptance of both perspectives (and more) as coexisting realities of self. In some context one perspective may shape the other and grow together but in other context both may hold claims of truth within. We often believe that a pastor must always be a model for others in his or her life. Suddenly when we hear that he or she has broken the social norms it becomes a shock to our mindset. It is difficult to accept him or her back to be the pastor. But if he or she has been helpful to us in many ways then the other, we look for the way to help out the pastor to get over this and see him or her to be back again as pastor. Though it takes a long time to accept him back we recognize the other perspective of acceptance and not compromise with our principles. This is where the difficulty of holding dialogue with other perspectives arises. Many would not recognize the other perspectives within their ‘self’s immediately rather they object to others who tends to look at other ways too. Only when it comes to personal experience of accepting our own or with those closely linked with our family then we begin to recognize their different perspectives. When a person begins to recognize his or her own perspectives then it becomes easily possible to hold dialogue with others. Dialogue within oneself affirms one’s life, faith, dignity and also of others and proper relationship within self and with others. When one extends this dialogue within the self to others then it becomes narrative of dialogue.

Let me summarize this attempt to theologize dialogue at grassroots by highlighting the importance of recognizing different perspectives within God’s self. This is reflected in every human being through the image of God. Jesus became the model of recognizing this multiple perspectives within himself. To encourage people to hold dialogue at grassroots we need to recognize God’s characteristics in this way. Christians do not need to change their faith or give up their uniqueness claims of Christ in order to have dialogue with other religious communities. Other religious communities may have their own experience of God and narratives and do not need to give up their faith to have dialogue with Christians. We need to affirm together life, dignity, faith and relationship with each other which is being challenged by many of the life threatening and destructive narratives and hold dialogue with anyone who would like to share their perspectives with us. This should lead to contact, sharing, relationship and understanding with friends of all religions. Having recognized the importance of dialogue and theology of dialogue at grassroots we may have to consider this as part of theological formation of the pastors and leave this for discussion in the public and thus encourage people to come together regardless of their differences in religion, caste and race.



Freire, P. Pedagogy of the Oppressed. Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1972.

Freire, P and Shor I. A Pedagogy for Liberation. Dialogues on Transforming Education. London: Macmillan, 1987.

Gadamer, H-G. Truth and Method. London: Sheed and Ward, 1979.

Bakhtin, M. M. (1981). Discourse in the novel. In M. Holquist (Ed.), The dialogic imagination: four essays by M. M. Bakhtin. (C. Emerson & M. Holquist, Trans.). Austin: University of Texas Press.
Bakhtin, M. M. (1984). Rabelais and his world. (H. Iswolsky, Trans.). Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
Bakhtin, M. M. (1986). Speech genres and other late essays. (V. McGee, Trans.). Austin: University of Texas Press.
Bakhtin, M. M. (1981). The dialogical imagination. (M. Holquist, Ed.) Austin: University of Texas Press.
Bakhtin, M. (1984b). Problems of Dostoevsky's poetics. (C. Emerson, Ed. and Trans.), Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
Buber, M. [1958] I and Thou, 2nd edn. Camelot Press: Southampton

Arnett, R. C. (1986). Communication and community. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press.

Jürgen Habermas, 1990Moral Consciousness and Communicative Action. Cambridge: MIT Press.

Jürgen Habermas, 1987The Theory of Communicative Action vol. 2 Lifeworld and System: A Critique of Functionalist Reason. Boston: Beacon Press.


Bohm, D 1998, On Creativity. Routledge: London.
Bohm, D. 1996 On Dialogue. Routledge: London.

Jung C G. (1969) The Structure and Dynamics of the Psyche, C.W. 8. Princeton University Press.
Jung C G. 1969, Psychology and Religion: West and East, C.W. 11. Princeton Universtiy Press.
Jung C G. 1971, Psychological Types, C.W. 6. Princeton University Press.

Jung, C.G. 1961, Memories, Dreams, Reflections. Vintage Books.
[1] For convenient sake only I describe God with exclusive language that describes God in third person as ‘him’. I do not assume God either as male or as female.





No comments:

Post a Comment